MADISON TOWNSHIP — A Madison school board meeting Wednesday began with a celebration of student excellence and ended with a bleak message about the district’s financial future.
After highlighting 19 students who earned perfect state test scores, honoring two staff members for going above and beyond and sampling treats prepared by the Madison Middle School cooking club, the board heard an update from Treasurer Bradd Stevens about what comes next after an attempt to renew two operating levies failed last month.
The board then approved a deficit reduction plan, something the Ohio Department of Education and Workforce requires of districts in fiscal oversight.
The plan included the elimination of 27 positions ahead of the 2027-2028 school year.
Specific positions were not listed. The plan states cuts would include 18 certified staff positions, two administrators and seven support staff positions.
The district’s contract with the teachers’ union requires administrators to finalize the list of positions to be eliminated by mid-April. Supt. Rob Peterson said he hopes to have it sooner.
“When you’re cutting staff, you want people to know that as early as possible, so they can begin the process for seeking out new positions,” he said.
Madison Local Schools was placed under fiscal oversight in August due to financial projections that showed the district is on track to run out of operating funds by the end of the 2027-2028 school year.
The failure of a renewal levy during last month’s election only worsened the district’s financial projections.
Stevens said the cuts outlined in the plan will save the district about $1.84 million over the course of the 2027-2028 school year.
But the district is still estimated to spend more than $308,000 more than it takes in next school year.
The plan also includes some revenue generating measures, including:
- Charging a $25,000 annual administrative fee to the Madison Adult Education Program, starting this school year.
- Charging a $25,000 annual administrative fee to the Madison Early Childhood Learning Center, starting this school year.
- Increasing pay-to-participate fees for athletics and clubs, starting in the fall of 2028.
- Increasing student usage fees for technology, starting in fall 2028.
Together, those fees are estimated to generate around $108,000 in additional annual revenue for the district.
Madison will likely reattempt levy renewal in May
Madison residents rejected a combined levy renewal on Election Day by a total of 61 votes, according to results certified last week by the Richland County Board of Elections.
(The gap was slightly wider — 78 votes — in the unofficial vote count on Election Day.)
The ballot measure would not have raised taxes, but would have continued the collection of a 6.9-mill and 7.5-mill levy, which generate more than $4.6 million in operating funds each year.
Peterson said the board will likely call a work session later this month to discuss whether or not to put the combined levy renewal back on the ballot in May.
Even with the cuts outlined in Wednesday’s plan, the district is projected to run out of funds by the end of the 2028-2029 school year without the renewal.
If the levy renewal does not pass in May, the district will need to complete another deficit reduction plan in Aug. 2027 and cut an additional $3 million to avoid running out of operating funds over the course of the 2028-2029 school year.
Stevens said the levies are necessary to avoid a state takeover of the district’s finances.
“It’s not really much of a choice because if we don’t do something and the levy doesn’t pass, the next step will be fiscal emergency,” Stevens told the board.
“When that happens, the Ohio Department of Education has a voting commission that basically takes over.”
Madison has already made budget cuts in recent years. The district eliminated 37 full time jobs and closed an elementary school at the end of last school year.
“We don’t have a spending problem. We have a revenue problem,” Stevens said. “If we don’t pass anything in May, we’re going to be doing this again, same time next year.”
What happens if a renewal passes in May?
If the levy does pass, finances will be better, but still tight.
Currently, Madison is projected to have just seven days’ worth of cash on hand at the end of the school year. By the end of the 2027-2028 school year, the district is on track to have just four days’ cash on hand.
Stevens projected a successful renewal would enable Madison to end the 2027-2028 school year with about nine days’ cash on hand and the 2028-2029 school year with around 16 days’ cash on hand.
How much cash on hand should a school district have?
Having cash on hand ensures a district can continue operating even if there is an interruption with regular revenue streams like property tax payments or payments from the state.
The Government Finance Officers Association recommends carrying an unrestricted fund balance of at least 60 days’ worth of operating expenses.
Ohio Association of School Business Officials recommends schools districts have at least 90 days’ cash on hand.
None of those estimates include a base pay raise for employees during the next round of contract negations, which begin early next year.
Meanwhile, Stevens said the district can’t wait until the results of a May levy come in to make cuts because administrators must notify the teacher’s union of a planned reduction-in-force by March 1, per the parties’ negotiated agreement.
Declining enrollment, rising insurance costs continue to strain the district budget
Stevens projected a budget of $39 million for this school year. Employee salaries (48 percent) and benefits (35.4 percent) make up the majority of those costs.
Madison is projected to spend $203,031 more than it brings in during the current fiscal year.
Stevens said inflation, specialized student service costs and health insurance prices all impact the district and are outside of its control.
“I’m doing the best we can when it comes to electricity costs, hedging them,” he said. “But there are certain things that we can’t control.”
Meanwhile, the per-pupil funding Madison receives from the state is projected to be about $700,000 less this year as a result of an unexpected enrollment decline of 111 students.
“Our August forecast anticipated a decline, but actual enrollment for the 2026-2027 school year was lower than originally projected,” Stevens said. “This resulted in a larger reduction in state funding than we initially anticipated.”
Stevens said only two grades at Madison — 5th and 12th — have more than 200 students.
But Stevens since those 111 students were spread across grade levels and buildings, their departure doesn’t translate into lower costs for the district.
“You divide that 111 kids by 12 grade levels, it doesn’t eliminate a teacher,” he said.
“You still have to have the same number of custodians, you still have to have the same number of cooks, you still have to have the same number of principals,” he added. “It’s not enough to eliminate $700,000 worth of positions.”
