SHELBY, Ohio – In order to take in the distinct history, character and heritage of the city of Shelby, all you have to do is look up. Shelby’s central historic district along Main Street provides visible evidence of the city’s past, and the passage of a new ordinance looks to preserve this evidence for future generations to enjoy.
On Feb. 17, Shelby City Council passed a historic preservation ordinance for the purpose of preserving Shelby’s distinctive character and its “cultural, social, residential, commercial, industrial, educational, political, or architectural heritage for the enjoyment, enrichment and benefit of the citizens of Shelby.” Councilmember Garland Gates spearheaded the effort to pass the ordinance.
“With the ordinance council has passed, it’s a model I think will work quite well,” said Gates. “It’s not a situation where big government will come in and tell people what they can do. It’s a voluntary, collaborative program, and my hope is when property owners see what benefits they might be eligible for because their property is being designated a local landmark, they would come forward so they can access that.”
Gates explained the passage of the ordinance creates a Historic Preservation Committee, made up of five members to be appointed by Shelby Mayor Steve Schag. The ordinance states all commission members shall have a demonstrated special interest, experience, or knowledge of historic preservation, history, architecture, or related disciplines. At least two members of the commission shall be preservation-related professionals.
The duties of the commission will be to promote historic preservation and educate Shelby citizens about historic preservation, as well as recommending to city council the designation of landmarks and historic districts. The commission will also work with property owners in Shelby to designate eligible landmarks, building or structures on the National Register of Historic Places and to participate in the Ohio Historic Inventory.
“The register is a way for the federal government to recognize building structures, places, and locations that have some historical significance,” Gates explained. “The historical significance in this case recognizes that history occurs on the local level as well.”
Currently two Shelby buildings are on the National Register of Historic Places: Most Pure Heart of Mary Church for its Romanesque architecture, and Marvin Memorial Library for its Greek Revival architecture. The Shelby Center Historic District downtown is also on the register for examples of Italianate, Queen Anne and Neo-Classical architecture.
Perhaps the most important function of the historic preservation ordinance is bringing the city of Shelby one step closer to becoming a Certified Local Government (CLG) – a federal-state-local partnership for protecting historic resources. By becoming a CLG, Shelby would become eligible for training, technical assistance and additional benefits from the Ohio Historic Preservation Office and for CLG grants to cover the costs of historic preservation planning, surveys and inventories.
“It’s good for the municipality in that it’s taking local interests and helping to guide their local development,” said Nathan Bevil, CLG and preservation services manager with the Ohio Historic Preservation Office. “Preservation occurs at the local level. It’s helping them guide their development and thoughtfully consider development; preservation is helpful to make thoughtful and careful decisions about land use and how buildings change. It’s helping to guide the growth.”
Gates noted Shelby’s Community Improvement Corporation (CIC) is already looking to revitalize the central historic district downtown with a façade program, using local dollars to help property owners maintain and improve their building facades.
“What we’ve seen over the years, if an architectural style had gone out of popularity, any number of facades were put on buildings that are not part of the original building,” said Gates. “The façade program would restore that and try to bring the building back to what it was originally intended to be.”
By becoming a CLG, more dollars would be available to Shelby through grants for similar restorations. Bevil agreed Shelby’s downtown historical architecture would be key for growth and reinvestment locally.
“It’s reusing what you’ve already got,” he said. “It’s cliché to say, but it’s true that the greenest building is the one that’s already built. There are great old materials that can stand a lot of wear and tear, and a lot of buildings close to the heart of downtown, so why not think about reusing some of those?”
Ultimately the passage of the ordinance is only one step in the process. Gates noted the ordinance leading the way to becoming a CLG, the façade program, and other city projects such as Blackfork Commons, will all come together to create a more viable downtown.
“Healthy communities have healthy downtowns,” he said.

