MADISON TOWNSHIP — The sale of the former Mifflin Elementary School is on pause due a title issue dating back to horse-and-buggy days.

Mifflin Elementary closed at the end of the 2025-2026 school year, due to declining enrollment and financial challenges facing the Madison Local School District.

The school board voted to auction the property, which consists of six parcels totaling 10.28 acres of land. The auction went live on October. 24 and was set to end on Nov. 3.

But about halfway through that time period, the property was pulled offline.

“As the title company was going through the process of clearing the title, they came across a lease agreement from 1886 for one parcel of that property,” Supt. Rob Peterson said during a school board meeting on Wednesday.

The lease agreement is between Mary B. Gongwer and the now-defunct Mifflin Township Board of Education. It did not include a timeline or expiration date, according to Peterson.

It applies to one of the six parcels, located on the corner of Reed Road and U.S. 430. The parcel is 1.5 acres.

Peterson said that per the terms of the lease, ownership would revert back to Gongwer or her heirs if the land is no longer used for school purposes.

The superintendent said the district has the option to sell the other five parcels, but has opted to try “quieting the title” to the sixth parcel so it can be included in the sale.

“I have had multiple conversations with the title company and an attorney who’s representing us in this case, and in order to clear the title, which they call it, quiet the title, we have to file a complaint with the court,” Peterson said.

“As part of that process, we have to complete what’s called a notice of publication, which basically you are publicizing once a week for six weeks in the news media and essentially giving the heirs an opportunity to come forward and contest the quieting of the title.”

Peterson said that process is beginning and should take about two months. If an heir comes forward to contest the quieting of the title, the process could cost the district between $6,000 and $8,000.

“If nobody comes forward, it’ll be significantly less than that,” he said. “Once the title is quieted, then the intention is to re-auction the property and we’ll go from there.”

Peterson called the situation an “odd circumstance.”

“I know there was some concern out there that the district didn’t do its due diligence. That is not the case,” he said.

“In speaking with the title agency, all processes were followed as they should have been. We had the right people employed to do those things. The person that I spoke to, she said she had been in the title business for over 30 years and this is the third one of these that she’s seen.”

Madison Local Schools celebrated its centennial last year. Mifflin Elementary was built in 1949.

Richland Source was unable to verify when the Mifflin Board of Education dissolved at the time of publication.

Staff reporter at Richland Source since 2019. I focus on education, housing and features. Clear Fork alumna. Always looking for a chance to practice my Spanish. Got a tip? Email me at katie@richlandsource.com.