When Jake and Christina Simpkins first saw the long tree-lined driveway leading to the sandstone home on North Stewart Road, they knew they had found something extraordinary. What began as a house hunt soon became a passion project that brought new life to one of Mansfield’s most historic homes.
Tucked quietly at 291 N Stewart Road, the Greek Revival sandstone estate is recognized on the National Register of Historic Places as the Samuel Lewis House. Built from locally quarried Mansfield sandstone, it has endured the Civil War, the Great Depression, and the city’s growth, standing as one of the largest and best-preserved antebellum homes in Richland County.
Jake and Christina originally dreamed of opening a bed and breakfast later in life, but when opportunity met timing, that dream took shape sooner than expected.
“Jake left the corporate world to take it on,” said Christina. “We loved meeting the people who stayed with us, sitting down at breakfast, hearing their stories, and sharing our own.”
Guests came from all over and left glowing reviews. Some described the experience as “like stepping back in time,” while others compared it to “staying in a castle.” One guest wrote, “After staying here, I will do my best to never stay at a hotel again. Jake was an amazing host who made five-star breakfasts to die for.”
Operating as The Safe House Bed & Breakfast, the property became a beloved local destination known for its warmth and hospitality. The home’s thoughtful layout made it ideal for hosting guests. Each of the six bedrooms included its own full bath, and the spacious living areas provided both comfort and privacy. A gourmet kitchen, original wood floors, and abundant natural light added to its welcoming charm.
Beyond the house itself, the setting made the experience unforgettable. Over nine wooded acres surround the property, with English gardens, a stream, and walking trails where deer are often seen grazing. A 24×30-foot barn, hot tub, and large deck made it as functional as it was beautiful.
For the Simpkins family, it was more than a business.
“We loved sharing this home we cherish so much,” said Christina. “We hope the next owners will see the same potential, whether as a bed and breakfast or a family home. It deserves to be filled with life and laughter.”The Safe House stands today as a testament to craftsmanship, community, and care. Its history gives it character, and its peaceful setting gives it heart. For those who dream of combining home and hospitality, 291 N Stewart Road offers a rare chance to carry on a legacy of welcome that began nearly two centuries ago.
Property Highlights: 291 N Stewart Road, Mansfield, Ohio 44905
- Listed on the National Register of Historic Places as the Samuel Lewis House
- Built from locally quarried Mansfield sandstone and expanded in 1999
- Nearly 4,000 square feet of living space with six bedrooms and four full baths
- Original wood floors, tall ceilings, and abundant natural light
- Gourmet kitchen with stainless steel appliances and a large dining area
- Family room with fireplace and a flexible fitness or laundry space
- Nine wooded acres featuring English gardens, a stream, and walking trails
- Outdoor amenities include a 24×30-foot barn, hot tub, and above-ground pool with deck
For more information, visit https://slussrealty.com/properties/1240-Residential-291-N-Stewart-Road-Mansfield-Ohio-44905-6-Bedrooms-4-Bathrooms-USD490-000/
