MANSFIELD — Alayna Ross was like any little girl growing up around Lexington, dreaming of being Cinderella and meeting Prince Charming at a fabulous ball.

Those dreams become theatrical musical reality on Friday night at the Mansfield Playhouse when the community theater begins a two-weekend run of the famous  Rodgers and Hammerstein musical.

“Cinderella’s always been a part of my childhood,” the 24-year-old Lexington High School graduate said. “I had the (musical) on VHS when I was little and I played it until the tape wore out.”

That admiration for Julie Andrews and other actresses who have portrayed Cinderella helped convince Ross to return to the Playhouse stage for the first time since January 2022 in the lead role.

The local show and its cast of 20 follows largely the same storyline that the famed composers created for Andrews in the live TV version in 1957.

Cinderella (Alayna Ross) is visited by her Fairy Godmother (Tori O’Brien) Credit: Carl Hunnell

It has all the characters audiences have known and loved, including the mean stepmother and stepsisters, the Fairy Godmother, the King and Queen and the magical carriage.

It also has the classic Rodgers & Hammerstein music and lyrics, including “Impossible/It’s Possible,” “In My Own Little Corner” and “The Prince is Giving a Ball.”

“I knew that it was a classic and I was excited to be a part of the original production. That excited me, being a part of the original,” said Ross, who has remained active behind the scenes at the Playhouse choreographing children’s musicals.

Adult musical returns to Mansfield Playhouse

The chance to return an adult musical to the Mansfield Playhouse stage also excites Artistic Director Doug Wertz.

The last such production was several years ago with “Little Shop of Horrors.”

“I think one of the biggest concerns that we’ve had was scheduling musical directors. It’s a small pool to be able to get ahold of them, especially when we do the other two children’s musicals a year,” Wertz said.

“Most of our musical directors are teachers and educators and it’s hard because of their school requirements,” Wertz said.

Musicals also come with a higher cost.

The king (Aaron McNulty) chats with his son Prince Charming (Cameron Wertz) Credit: Carl Hunnell

“Putting on musicals, production wise for the rental of the equipment, and the royalties, the scripts, the librettos, and it’s all rental. The music, if you’re using orchestration tracks, it’s incredibly expensive.

“It makes it very difficult for community theaters to do. But we also felt like if we want to continue to grow and bring people in and and serve the community with what they want, then we decided to invest in a nice musical,” Wertz said.

(GALLERY: Below are photos taken during a dress rehearsal this week of “Cinderella” at the Mansfield Playhouse.)

  • Cinderella
  • Cinderella
  • Cinderella
  • Cinderella
  • Cinderella

Like father, like son

The show also offers Wertz a chance to again work with his son, Cameron, 20, who grew up doing youth shows at the Playhouse with his father.

Cameron Wertz last performed at the Playhouse in December as Santa in “The Life and Adventures of Santa Claus.”

Cast now as Prince Charming, the younger Wertz relishes working with his dad again.

“I love it and I miss it,” he said of performing. “My dad I get get along really well and we work well together,” said Wertz, who works as a CNC machinist at Lennox Machine in Mansfield.

“I haven’t been able to help him with the set or anything because of work. I never have time. But the time I have gotten to work with him, it’s been a blast,” Cameron Wertz said.

Doug Wertz said other performers helped convince Cameron Wertz to audition.

“Growing up in the musical theater, children’s productions, he really likes the musical theater aspect of it.

“So it was hard to get him to do anything, once he reached the age of leaving the children’s program. Trying to get him to audition for any other role in an adult show was very tough.

“But when he saw this, he thought, ‘OK, yeah.’ It’s not a huge role, but he’s got some really nice songs. I don’t want to sound biased, but the kid’s got some pipes. He’s got a beautiful voice,” Wertz said.

A return to Cinderella

The show also gives Jamie Stima a chance to again perform in Cinderella, albeit in a different role. The 30-year-old was the vocal director and evil stepmother when St. Peter’s produced the show a couple of years ago.

“I had been looking to get back into performing. And so since I was familiar with the show anyway, I thought, that’s one of those shows I would love to do anything at all,” the 2011 St. Peter’s High School graduate said.

The queen (Jamie Stima) prepares for the ball. Credit: Carl Hunnell

“When I auditioned, I didn’t even say specifically the queen. I just said anything, I will take literally anything because it’s just a fun show,” said Stima, now an academic advisor at OSU-Mansfield.

“When I was cast as the queen, I’ve really enjoyed the role because she brings maturity and an adultness to the rest of the cast that doesn’t really exist anywhere else in the show. She helps make everyone funnier because of how she brings some of that maturity to play off of everybody else,” Stima said.

Ready for opening night

Producing a show like Cinderella in a community theater is a challenge. But Doug Wertz said the cast and crew have worked well together.

“They’ve been the greatest group. We’ve got some new people that have come in and this is the first time they’ve ever done anything that we’ve had here. We’ve had some that have directed shows in their schools and then they said, ‘I want to just see what’s different and what it’s like.’

” So they auditioned and … the voices sound like a studio recording,” Wertz said.

Ross, an academic advisor at Ashland University, acknowledges it’s a bit of a challenge to make a 66-year-old show pop in today’s world — while staying true to the idyllic characters.

“I think because it is so old, that (we are) trying to make it still a little bit modern,” she aid.

“But there is still the expectation that everybody knows Cinderella and it’s a part of everybody’s childhood. It doesn’t matter how old you are, you had Cinderella.

“I just hope that when people see the production that maybe for a moment, for an hour and a half or whatever, they can be little girls again … little ones again.”

“Cinderella’ details

“Cinderella” opens Friday, Sept. 8, at 8 p.m. at the Mansfield Playhouse. Other show dates are Sept. 9, 15 and 16 at 8 p.m. and Sept. 17 at 2:30 p.m.

Tickets for this musical are $15 for adults, $14 for seniors and $8 for students.

For tickets and reservations, call the Playhouse box office at 419-522-2883. Box office hours are Wednesday through Friday from 1 p.m. to 6 p.m. and one hour prior to all performances.

Tickets may also be purchased online at

The show is sponsored by Mechanics Bank, Taylor Metal Products and BP Electric. Season sponsors are Richland Source, iHeart Media, Mid-State Multimedia Group and Schmidt Security Pro.

Cast of Cinderella

Cinderella…Alayna Ross

Prince…Cameron Wertz

King…Aaron McNulty

Queen…Jamie Stima

Stepmother…Lentcen Roig

Portia…Elina Gilland

Joy…MaKaila Davis

Godmother… Tori O’Brien

Herald…Gage Workman

Chef…Samuel Hergatt

Steward…Noah Burton

Ensemble… Candy Boyd, Caelyn Brubaker, Joi Davis, Alyssa Erdenberger, Ian Hergatt, Mary Kettering, Jenn Lang, Alicia Porter, Kristy Slagle and Scott Allen Woodlee

Technical crew

Director — Doug Wertz

Musical director — Kim Wolbert

Choreographer — Beth Anne Jarvis

Stage manager — Kanashay Grayeagle

Set design and construction — Doug Wertz

Set painting crew — Doug Wertz, Tammy Wertz, Milla Wertz, Heidi Ankrum, Grace Ankrum, Evan Wertz and Daniella Araya

Sound engineer and operator — Jerry Calhoun

Light board operator — Kanashay Grayeagle

Projections operator — Doug Wertz

Props — Kanashay Grayeagle, Lynne Moore, Jerry Calhoun and Jennifer Briner

Stage crew — Lynne Moore, Tony Viscioni, Josie Burns, Christy Landon, Troy Landon

Hair and makeup — Lynne Moore and Megan Workman

Costumes — Candy Boyd, Tori O’Brien, Linda Newman, Abby Shewan, Noah Burton, Ginger Stoops, Christy Landon, Lorrie Williams, Aaron McNulty, Jamie Stima, Jenn Lang, Alicia Porter and Kristy Slagle

The Life & Culture section is powered by University Hospitals Samaritan Medical Center.

City editor. 30-year plus journalist. Husband. Father of 3 grown sons and also a proud grandpa. Prior military journalist in U.S. Navy, Ohio Air National Guard. -- Favorite quote: "Where were you when...