M Star Hotel

The M Star Hotel, 137 Park Ave. West, in downtown Mansfield recently sold for $650,000, according to property transfers filed with the Richland County Auditor's Office.

A downtown Mansfield hotel recently sold for $650,000, according to property transfers filed with the Richland County Auditor's Office.

The M Star Hotel, 137 Park Ave. West, was sold by NAGPAL Motels Mansfield, Inc., to NIJNAM, LLC, according to the paperwork filed with the sale.

According to the Ohio Secretary of State's Office, NINJAM, LLC, was incorporated in 2020 and is operated by Bhaveshkumar Patel from Mukwonago, Wisc.

What's Your Home Worth?

Results include up to 3 different estimated valuation sources.

NAGPAL Motels Mansfield, Inc., was formed in 2007, according to the secretary of state's office, operated by Warscha Nagpal.

According to an online listing for the property, the hotel features 43 rooms and has 19,012 square feet on the 0.63-acre lot. The listing said the hotel was built in 1964 and renovated in 2018.

The property transfer was among 190 such sales recently recorded with the county auditor's office.

Others were:


1095-1099 W. Longview Ave., Mansfield; CSM Properties of Mid-Ohio, LLC, to Richland Partners, LLC; $552,000

549 E. Townview Circle, Mansfield; William Rathburn to Woodland REI Partners; $67,500

519 Westview Blvd., Mansfield; James Taylor to Jeremy Walker; $139,050

78 S. Brookwood Way, Mansfield; James and Karen Simmermon to Heather Stover, LLC; $50,000

309 and 311 Tower Drive, Mansfield; KNL Associates, LLC, to Troy Tinkham; $120,000

743 McPherson St., Mansfield; Lecia Ream and Timothy Salsgiver to Rodney Ochoa; $52,000

165 Ashland Road, Mansfield; RSK Properties, Inc., to RJE Properties of Mansfield, LLC; $500,000

1175 Woodland Road, Mansfield; Karl Jr. and Ilea Goettl to Marilyn Flanegan; $119,000

616 Cline Ave., Mansfield; William Freytag to Mary Zehnder; $82,000

225 Oak St., Mansfield; Geraldine Anderson to Prince Pipeline Integrity, LLC; $110,000

551 Park Ave. West, Mansfield; Jeffrey Zody to Joseph Gould; $129,500

472 W. Sixth St., Mansfield; MSMJ Investments, LLC, to Taylorwood Properties, LLC; $18,250

88 Carpenter Road, Mansfield; Terry Blackburn and Dan Hellinger to Sherry Berry; $40,000

107 Glenwood Blvd., Mansfield; Wanda Dean Preservation Trust to Alexandra Ortega and Jordan Melton; $153,000

36 Hoffman Ave., Mansfield; David Morehead to Anna Cottone; $44,000

1090 Burkwood Road, Mansfield; Jedidiah Mastin to Craig and Andria Freeman; $159,000

625 Courtwright Blvd., Mansfield; JCKV Properties, LLC, to Jason and Helena Stone; $121,500

286 Grace St., Mansfield; RJ Hunt Properties, LLC, to Leroy Miller, trustee; $47,500

623 Bailey Drive, Unit 2, Mansfield; Maulikkumar Patel and Pujabahen to Kelli and Jonathan Bank; $44,000

336 W. 5th St., Mansfield; Richard Bays to Amonda and Steven Lowe Sr.; $11,000

388 Wood St., Mansfield; Joseph Schramm to Lester Garber; $15,000

516 Davidson St., Mansfield; TAT Rental Properties, LLC, to Sarah Smith; $152,000

243 Stadium St. and 976 W. 4th St., Mansfield; RNP-21, LLC, to CLH-1, LLC; $100,000

243 Stadium St. and 976 W. 4th St., Mansfield; Property Acquisition Associations, LLC, and Paseo, LLC, to J. Riley, LLC; $275,182

243 Stadium St. and 976 W. 4th St., Mansfield; Paseo, LLC, and RNO-9, LLC, to M. Eric Grant; $650,000

243 Stadium St. and 976 W. 4th St., Mansfield; RNP-21, LLC, to RNP-9, LLC; $307,499.19

243 Stadium St. and 976 W. 4th St., Mansfield; RNP-21, LLC, to Paseo, LLC; $380,000

282 Bartley Ave., Mansfield; Marhaba, LLC, to Renovate 1st, LLC; $100,000

1642 Nantucket Drive, Mansfield; Timothy Welsh, trustee, to Christopher and Stacey Baldasare; $280,000

1909 Sandy Court, Mansfield; Donna Hamilton to Donald Coots Jr.; $149,500

Vacant lot, 215 Oak St., Mansfield; Norfolk Southern Railway Co. to Kokosing Materials, Inc.; $8,000

1915 Sandy Court, Mansfield; Virginia and Frederick Crowgey III to Adrienne and Jason Lester; $50,000

269 Parkway Drive, Mansfield; Eric Quinn to Ignacio Gaytan; $11,500

114 Dawson Ave., Mansfield; Donita and David Mosley to Robert Monet; $79,900

633 Coleman Road, Mansfield; James and Marva Huff to Jonah Ours; $133,000

470 Newman St., Mansfield; Jimmie Nelson to M & D Real Estate Investments, LTD; $70,000

701 Millsboro Road, Mansfield; Sandra Garner to Joshua and Markellla Winemiller; $124,500

671 Weller Ave., Mansfield; Charlotte Daugherty, Benjamin Daugherty and Frank Daugherty to John and Sue Rettig; $185,000

383 3rd Ave., Mansfield; Jason Rose to Brian Zapior and Melinda Fites; $20,000

752 York St. West, Mansfield; Getz Builders, Inc., to Lori Cope; $303,100.22

648 Trenton Court, Mansfield; Robert and Marilyn Humeston, co-trustees, to Daniel Kardasz and Amanda Liska; $195,000

221 Glessner Ave., Mansfield; Jeffrey Wakeley to William Barber; $15,000

936 Paxford Place, Mansfield; Estate of Jesse Carsey Jr. to Brian Benick; $72,000

967 Linwood Place, Mansfield; Jayma Wink to Henry and Kymberlee Lisk; $189,900

641 Manchester Road, Mansfield; Nathan Ernst to Nathan and Holly Coons; $124,000

343-345 Lexington Ave., Mansfield; Merry Birmelin to Abdul, Ltd,; $67,000

276 W. Third St., Mansfield; Nancy and Douglas Jones to Mike Conrad; $500

312 Sturges Ave., Mansfield; Katherine Balg to Craig Monthomery; $14,000

575 Dirlam Lane, Mansfield; Evan and Brittany Hill, co-trustees, to Keshia Allen and Pamela Trumpower; $185,000

227 Elmwood Drive, Mansfield; Crystal Taylor to Heavyn Lilley; $71,000

Vacant lot, 225 Eighth Ave., Mansfield; Levi Harris to Pamela and Steven Brown; $3,000

91 Wood St., Mansfield; Clearcreek Rentals, LLC, to Simpson Homes, LLC; $9,900

634 Brandywine Drive, Mansfield; Gregory and Sally Kibler to Austin Pratt; $192,500

255 Taylor Road, Mansfield; Connor and Kaci Griggs to Leann Means; $80,000

Vacant lot, Kennedy Drive, Mansfield; Thomas Watson to Thomas Kososky II; $8,500

484 Sloan Ave., Mansfield; Nathan Zehe and Rachelle Faulds-Zehe to Ralph Ritchey; $105,000

940 Maumee Ave., Mansfield; Lawrence and Jo Ann Oney to Black Dog Properties, LLC; $79,900

171 Poplar St., Mansfield; LAJI Properties of Mansfield, LLC, to Susan Maul; $19,900

649 Logan Road, Mansfield; Brandon and Vanessa Heffelfinger to James Townsend; $144,900

1260 Lexington Ave., Mansfield; Donald and Shirley Brown to KBST Enterprises, LLC; $200,000

175 Bennett St., Mansfield; Charity and Craig Moore to Stephen Mitchell; $96,900

Vacant lot, West Park Avenue, Mansfield; Little Buckeye Children's Museum to Renaissance Performing Arts Association, Inc.; $3,750

568 Heineman Blvd., Mansfield; Thomas and Jamie Carroll to Capital Bounty, LLC; $70,000

152 Poplar St., Mansfield; Joseph Jerger, guardian, to Tracy Bond; $36,250

636 Sherwood Drive, Mansfield; Michael Grist to Richard and Catherine Wiehe; $139,900

476 Clifton Blvd., Mansfield; James Myers to Terri McInturf; $115,500

492 W. Fourth St., Mansfield; Barbara Boyd to Ahmed Hammad; $15,000

781 Grace St., Mansfield; Timothy and Diane Sublett to Teddy and Carol Vail; $54,000

75 Sturges Ave., Mansfield; Great Land Real Estate Investment, LLC, to D.W. Fisher Properties, LLC; $739000

800-802 Grace St. and 705-707 Ashland Road, Mansfield; David Wadley, trustee, to Scott McEndree; $175,000

339 Muth Road, Mansfield; James Braden, executor, to Matthew Sanford; $62,000


2027 Willowood Drive North, Ontario; Brant and Tonya Adams to Bennick Brothers, Ltd.; $20,000

680 E. Debby Lane, Ontario; David and Paula Keiper to Timmy and Twila Evans; $332,400

640 Hannah Faith Circle, Ontario; Robert and Sonya Ohl to Chad and Amanda Miller; $40,000

45 S. Harding Heights Blvd., Ontario; Estate of Sherry Swank to Joshua and Crystal Hughes; $80,000

357 Auburn Ave., Mansfield; Black Dog Rentals, LLC, to Phala Blake; $20,000

1.55 acres of vacant land, Park Avenue West, Ontario; Ontario Enterprises, Ltd., to Collin and Desiree Barkdull; $90,000

60 Bethel Lane, Ontario; Bradley Griffith to Laura Speelman; $144,000

335 Shelby-Ontario Road, Ontario; Andrea Taylor to Top Flight Real Estate, LLC; $23,000

2592 Fairway Crossing, Ontario; Estate of Betha Lambert to Dakota and Kayla Durbin; $305,000

715 Larry Court, Ontario; Robert and Sonya Ohl to Shope Investments, LLC; $38,000

1025 Elizabeth Ave., Mansfield; Jeffrey and Karen Virden to Dominick and Samantha Strassell; $9,000

560 Springmill St., 564 Springmill St., Springmill Street and Woodland Street, Mansfield; Donald Zeiters to Moustafa Ahmed; $18,000

154 S. Lexington-Springmill Road, Ontario; Michael Eyerly to Colleen Carter; $105,000


Vacant lot, Cold Draw, Shelby; Phillips Investments, Ltd., to Danny and Lois Robertson, trustees; $38,500

164 Broadway St., Shelby; WM Capital Partners 68, LLC, to Marilyn Wise; $39,534.66

10 Oak St., Shelby; JPMorgan Chase Bank to Jason Poth; $20,000

54-56 E. Main St., Shelby; Elisha and Matthew Kempf to Lynette Barclay; $48,780

119 Knoll View Circle, Shelby; Mark and Rebecca Coe to Lance Gutchall and Carin Chuvala; $260,000

55 Carleton Ave., Shelby; Barbara Armintrout to Heather Knapp and Jacoby Osborne; $3,000

76 Park Ave., Shelby; Matt and Robin Smedley to Jessica Reinhart; $65,000

33-35 Walnut St., Shelby; Elizabeth Yetzer, successor co-trustee, to Carl Schroeder; $84,000

11 Mickey Road, Shelby; Gerald Robertson, trustee, to Corey and Justina Barth; $125,000

12 Morningside Drive, Shelby; Hannah Wise to Glen and Brooklyn Lamb; $107,000

33 Faye Ave., Shelby; John Arms to Robin Langley; $154,000

131 Second St., Shelby; Mysti Bago to Timothy Dye; $75,000

5686 Ohio 61, Shelby; Louann Schroeder Revocable Living Trust to Ronald Morrison and Shawn Murphy; $50,000

5686 Ohio 61, Shelby; Home Roof Revocable Living Trust to Ronald Morrison and Shawn Murphy; $50,000

119 Knoll View Circle, Shelby; Sherrie Williams and Debra Smith to Mark and Rebecca Coe; $162,000

68 Broadway St., Shelby; Sandra Chilson to Camden Cornell; $16,500


Vacant lot, Ohio 97, Bellville; Daniel Galat, trustee, to Wardog, LLC; $25,000


176 Henry St., Butler; Charles Rogers to John Witschi; $130,500


1341 County Line Road, Crestline; The Church of God in Ohio to Bulldog Store and Lock It, LLC; $90,000


191 Hampton Road, Lexington; Jaymelee Glaspy to Ricky and Joanne Hartline; $125,000

108 Templeton Terrace, Lexington; Ricky and Joanne Hartline to Orville Lawrence; $170,900

22 Avon Drive, Lexington; Richelle Ettel to Brandon Bickers; $138,500

313 Sherwood Drive, Lexington; Zachary and Shirley Mueller to Thomas and Shantana Polk; $162,900

101 Otterbein Drive, Mansfield; Gilbert Hannigan to Joseph Bradbury; $233,000

166 Essex Road, Lexington; Dominick and Samantha Strassell to Lauryn Thoman and Harrison Floyd; $135,000

Vacant lot, 1361 Bella Vista, Lexington; Matthew and Stacy Oswalt to Donald Barnard; $1,500


83 Pleasant St., Lucas; Gary Kline and Melinda Claypool to Brandon Green; $60,000


4810 Vermillion St., Olivesburg; Michael Goon to Joshua Mobley; $15,000


Vacant lot, Plymouth; Brandon and Kayley Walcher to Randal and Kimberly Stephens; $2,000

335 W. Broadway St., Plymouth; James Cunningham and Janeane Hopkins to Richard and Linda Hetler; $69,900


Vacant land, Olivesburg-Fitchville Road, Shiloh; Joyce Gurton and Lorie Hickey, co-executors, to Gary Ramsay; $4,400


4348 Plymouth-Springmill Road, Shelby; Gary and Janet Keller to Joni Crenshaw; $145,000

Vacant land, Roush Road, Shelby; John Stiefel and Johnny Gibson to Carl Schroeder; $393,720

1580 Taylortown Road, Mansfield; David Amert to Travis Robinson and Ashley Lambert; $145,000

4142 Wareham Road, Shelby; Brian Crall to Troy and Gwen Schwemley; $262,500


5489 Durbin Road, Bellville; Janet Dearth and Frank Beach III to Benjamin and Denise Bethea; $148,000

5485 Mann Road, Bellville; Patricia Thomas to Randall and Karen Freeman; $120,000

11.12 acres of vacant land, Kenton Road, Bellville; Joseph Schramm to Martin Leslie; $210,000


1177 Eastview Drive, Mansfield; Deborah Larrick, Kelly Larrick Serral and Brian Larrick to Jeffrey and Ann Martin; $153,500

911 Mansfield-Washington Road, Mansfield; Thomas and Shirley Ball to Issac and Gillian Rebel; $71,000

354 Vernon Road, Mansfield; Robert Berry and Steven Berry to Timothy Risinger; $53,000

631 Morgan Ave., Mansfield; Justin and Kimberly Gerich to Ignacio Gaytan; $17,000

1430 Virginia Lane, Mansfield; Robin Shafer to Joshua Ramirez and Jessica Tager; $135,000

1142 Burger Ave., Mansfield; Justin King to Pamela Oney; $18,000

1127-1129 Eastview Drive, Mansfield; Timothy Bowersock to Michelle Anderson; $200,000

315 Lee Lane, Mansfield; Ashley Brown to Amanda Kolmansberger; $118,000

1134 Cairns Road, Mansfield; Mark Bond to Paul and Betty Bond; $80,000

1234 Cairns Road, Mansfield; Klupp Investments, LLC, to Timothy Bowersock; $165,000

1418 Ashland Road, Mansfield; Motter Associates to J & S Rentals of Ohio, LLC; $530,000

400 Piper Road, Mansfield; Reba Hunt, Shary Rose, Steven Head and William Head to Shary Rose and Clemont Rose Jr.; $57,350

1163 Keller Drive, Mansfield; Lawrence Jones to Ransom Adams and Monica Stearns; $113,550

1278 Grace St., Mansfield; Shirley Pew to Autumn Davidson and Cory Rook; $102,500

Burger Avenue, Mansfield; Buddy Dingus to John Yeichner, trustee; $7,500

1224 Bechtel Ave., Mansfield; Value Housing, LLC, to Jeffrey Arnholt; $85,000

971 Fleming Falls Road, Mansfield; Joshua and Tori Frech to Cody Mullins; $175,000


754 Touby Lane, Mansfield; Heather Deel to Kyle Harris; $184,900

840 Koogle Road, Mansfield; Jason Schwalm to Joshua and Tori Frech; $85,000

658 Woodcrest Drive, Mansfield; Jeffrey and Tina Nikolaus to Ashley Hetler; $245,000

32.90 acres, vacant land, abutting U.S. Route 30, Mansfield; Roy and Barbara Miller, trustees, to Elinor Jordan; $48,000

1400 Paradise View, Mansfield; Paradise Church to Fusion Church; $85,000

1125 Koogle Road, Mansfield; Goudy Properties, LLC, to Kingsley C.I. Properties, LLC; $155,000

79 Ford Road, Mansfield; Barbara Reid to Tim Wells; $32,500

2463 Wedgewood Drive, Mansfield; Beverly Thomas to Loman Cochran; $153,000

355 Harlan Road, Mansfield; Ronald and Karen Dapper to Steven and Ivanna Robinson; $198,900

3490 Shad Drive East, Mansfield; Shirley and Steve Williams and Nathan and Cassey Ernst; $175,000

76 N. Ford Road/Lorkay Drive, Mansfield; Edgewood Edgewater, LLC, to Edgewood Estates MHC, LLC; $235,000

76 N. Ford Road/Lorkay Drive, Mansfield; Edgewood Estates MHC, LLC, to Edgewood MHC, LLC; $689,000


1264 Mowery Road, Perrysville; Steven and Shirley Burdick to Matthew and Hollie Brenner; $250,000

Mowery Road, Perrysville; Steven and Shirley Burdick to Equity Trust Company; $250,000


3.78 acres of vacant land, Ohio 546, Bellville; Alec and Leesha Sprout to James and Cheryl Cullison; $35,000


89.52 acres, Opdyke Road, Plymouth; Paul Coovert, successor trustee, to Elvin and Miriam Zimmerman, trustees; $790,000


Vacant land, Ohio 309, Mansfield; John Hoffman, co-successor trustee, to Donald and Julie Starkey; $154,050

Vacant land, Ohio 309, Mansfield; John Hoffman, co-successor trustee, to Aaron and Jessica Kegley; $99,950

Vacant land, Ohio 309, Mansfield; John Hoffman, co-successor trustee, to Aaron and Jessica Kegley; $30,000

676 Marion Ave. Road North, Mansfield; Shirley Iseman to Nelson West, Elli West and Marthalee Wooldridge; $116,900

2438 Walker Lake Road, Mansfield; Melinda Studer to Kirby Clemens and Baylee Leonhardt; $151,470

Vacant lot, Springfield Circle, Mansfield; David and Patricia Schmitz to Benjamin and Brynn Hall; $60,000

Vacant lot, Joy Lynn Lane, Mansfield; Ronald Collins to Tommy and Ruby Knuckles; $2,100

1090 Pawnee Ave., Mansfield; Dean Squires to Dakota Wert; $53,000

Vacant lot, Kings Pointe Drive, Ontario; Harvey and Deena Maness to Thomas Kososky II; $27,500

693-695 Ohio 314 North, Mansfield; Brice Eyerly to Ricky Collins; $137,500

Vacant land, Springfield Circle, Mansfield; Nokautu Investments, LLC, to Michael and Jill Bender; $78,000

194 Rudy Road, Mansfield; Linda Drake to Mark and Laura Danals; $150,000


3499 W. Whitetail Drive, Lexington; Terri Haeseker, Elaine Bradley, Thomas Hampton, Bruce Hampton and Angela Wood to Zachary Picou; $240,000

3906 Ohio 42, Lexington; The Zirkle Family Revocable Trust to Krystal Sutherland and Zachary Litteral; $100,000

3112 Marion Ave. Road, Mansfield; Daniel Deskins to Gregory Fedro and Sylvia Hermo-Fedro; $161,000

Vacant land, Lakewood Drive, Mansfield; Daniel Deskins to Angela Hunsinger; $10,000

3731 Needham Road, Mansfield; Brad and Bethany Cunningham to Matthew and Dana Cain; $189,900


1699 S. Main St., Mansfield; Knox County Properties, LLC, to 1699 S Main St. LLC; $345,000

1965 Bellwood Road, Mansfield; Mary Simpson and Marcia Cadle to Larry and Ruth Carr; $125,000

3293 Ohio 13, Mansfield; Brenda Dennison to Megan and Ronald Lusk; $178,000

412 Alexander Road, Bellville; Richard and Dixie Gehrisch to Ronald Ferguson; $210,000

3959 Andrews Road, Bellville; David Thomas to Aaron Miller; $247,500

505 Alexander Road, Bellville; Alfred Ingold to Gary and Angela Perry; $164,000

2061 Washington North Road, Mansfield; Michael Procker to Jordan Mott; $500,000

1838 S. Main St., Mansfield; Elizabeth Miller to Karl Jr. and Ilea Goettl; $129,900

1651 W. Cook Road, Mansfield; Lori Cope to Malcolm Melton and Dierdre Carter-Melton; $174,900

51.98 acres of vacant land, Straub Road, Mansfield; Knox County Woodland, LTD, to Michael and Jacolyn Thiel; $193,500

72.97 acres, Terman Road, Mansfield; Raymond Mong, trustee, to Jerry and Rosann Troyer; $695,000


3775 Franklin Church Road, Mansfield; Peter and Stephanie Champer to Donald and Jennifer Van Meter; $280,000

3450 Ohio 545, Mansfield; Richard Cox, trustee, to Ronnie Webb Jr.; $124,900

4410 Ohio 545, Mansfield; Tony and Rochelle Shambaugh to Charles and Martha Schoonover; $60,000


1675 Wagner Road, Butler; Cornell and Darlene Webb to John Rideout; $220,000

4775 Possum Run Road, Bellville; Darrell Smith, Bruce Smith and David Smith to Kelly Brittingham; $153,500

Support Our Journalism

Our business readers can track who bought and sold property near them thanks to Source members. Are you a member? Join us today and keep these well-read monthly reports going.

City editor. 30-year plus journalist. Husband. Father of 3 grown sons and also a proud grandpa. Prior military journalist in U.S. Navy, Ohio Air National Guard. -- Favorite quote: "Where were you when the page was blank?"